Rev. Magee's replacement, Rev. William Thorne, wants Amaar and the Muslims out until he realizes his congregants like having the mosque around. Rayyan dances to country music in her wedding dress and returns gifts; one of them in which leads her to call J.J one last time.
When Amaar invites Rev. Thorne to co-host a party, the minister hijacks the planning and almost tanks the event. Yasir hires a new employee, Yusuf, who does not speak English, and tries to set him up with Rayyan. Rayyan gets revenge by pretending that she will marry Yusuf.
Rev. Thorne is stealing Amaar's sermons and preaching them to his own congregation. Rayyan decides to move out, much to her father's dismay.
After Rayyan bans pop-in visits, Sarah sneaks into Rayyan's house to retrieve her emergency key and gets trapped inside. Thorne tries to convert the Muslims to Christianity.